Dispute in Valladolid

In a time of exploration and discovery, Spain's conquistadors sailed across the unknown oceans, unearthing new worlds and diverse realities far removed from their European roots. Yet, as they encountered indigenous peoples in these territories, they were confronted with a profound question: do these native individuals possess souls?As the Church sought to protect and convert both natives and conquerors alike, many of the latter treated the former as mere commodities, ignoring the fundamental humanity that underpins all life. The Valladolid Controversy is born from this moral dilemma, with heated debates raging between those who believe the indigenous people should be accorded the same dignity and spirituality as Europeans and those who view them simply as objects for exploitation.At the heart of this conflict lies a cardinal tasked with the solemn responsibility of hearing both sides of the argument and seeking reasoned answers to this critical inquiry. Amidst the tumultuous backdrop of colonial expansion, the film explores themes of cultural clash, moral dilemma, and the eternal search for meaning as humanity grapples with the complexities of its own existence.